A Review of The Selection by Kiera Cass: A Dystopian Reality Show with a Twist
When I first picked up The Selection by Kiera Cass, I was curious about a book that blends romance and dystopia with a competitive flair. The premise—distant future, a royal selection of brides, and a caste system based on wealth—grabbed me. Little did I know that beyond the glittering facade lay a world that would have me laughing, cringing, and reflecting on the absurdities of societal norms.
At its core, The Selection revolves around America Singer, a relatable yet infuriating protagonist. She’s thrust into the spotlight as one of the chosen contestants vying for the prince’s affection in a televised competition rife with drama and intrigue. From the very beginning, America is portrayed as a complex character, navigating her feelings for her first love, Aspen, while grappling with her burgeoning feelings for Prince Maxon. America’s journey is relatable—who hasn’t felt torn between two choices? Yet, her decision-making process often left me shaking my head in disbelief, wondering if she had thought things through.
The world-building, however, is where Cass’s vision falters. The setup—a future where America is under Chinese rule due to an improbable invasion sparked by economic debt—feels less like a possible trajectory and more like a hastily thrown-together plot twist. The names—America, Aspen, and even the titular Selection—landed with an odd thud, leading to moments of unintended hilarity.
That said, the entertaining aspects of the book quickly overwhelmed its inconsistencies. Cass’s writing style is approachable and entertaining, peppered with humorous moments that make it a light quick read. I found myself laughing out loud at some of the dialogue, which is sometimes so over-the-top that it could qualify as unintentional satire. One standout moment was when America’s mother believed winning the Selection would solve all their problems. It’s a humorous reflection on the often-overinflated expectations we place on outward success.
What truly made this book a page-turner for me was the camaraderie between the girls in the competition—a fascinating glimpse into friendship under pressure, even if some dynamics perpetuated old stereotypes of women pitted against one another. The dialogues sometimes felt forced, yet they highlighted how vulnerable and complex relationships can be, especially in a competitive environment.
Despite its glaring flaws, there’s a certain charm to The Selection. It’s ideal for readers who enjoy lighthearted romance mixed with elements of drama and competition. If you’re looking for something thought-provoking, this may not be it. But for those seeking humor and a bit of escapism from reality, The Selection is undeniably entertaining.
In conclusion, Kiera Cass’s work might not win awards for world-building or character depth, but what it lacks in those areas, it compensates for with humor and relatable themes of love and self-discovery. If you’re ready to experience a whimsical ride of lavish gowns, heartbreak, and royal intrigue while laughing at the ridiculousness of it all, The Selection may just find a place on your reading list. Just remember: sometimes, the best entertainment lies in the absurd.
Discover more about The Selection (The Selection, #1) on GoodReads >>