Review of Insurgent (Divergent, #2) by Veronica Roth
From the moment I flipped open to the first page, Insurgent promised a continuation of the pulse-pounding adventure I loved in Divergent. Veronica Roth threw us back into the dystopian chaos of Chicago, and despite my mixed feelings about its execution, the exploration of selflessness and identity lingered with me long after I turned the final page.
Let’s dive into the heart of the matter: the pacing. Oh boy, where do I even begin? While Divergent had me racing through its exhilarating twists, Insurgent felt like a slow burn—complete with long stretches of dialogue that turned into white noise. At over 500 pages, the book seemed to drag, with an abundance of filler that left me impatient. I often found myself wishing for a content editor to trim down those meandering conversations. When excitement hit, it was a thrill, but those long passages sometimes felt like I was stuck in a waiting room, anxious for the next heartbeat of action.
And then there’s Tris. In the first book, I admired her fierceness, but in Insurgent, her constant angst over her actions—especially concerning Will—became grating. Her guilt, while deeply human, was a recurring theme that felt like a broken record. I found myself sharing her pain but eventually just wanted her to move on. The whole "self-sacrificing hero" trope took a toll as well. Watching her repeatedly risk her life felt less like courage and more like a plot device that wore thin fast. I mean, who wants to constantly watch the protagonist wrestle with their mortality without a solid emotional payoff?
Tobias, too, shifted from a charismatic mystique to a character who often felt one-dimensional. While his backstory offered interesting layers, his choice to confront his father publicly struck me as immature—making me want to shake some sense into him. Their relationship dynamics often swung like a pendulum, seldom stable, and it left me yearning for more depth and real conversations, rather than just passionate kisses and angst.
Now, let’s chat about some of the secondary characters. Lynn, Uriah, and the like brought a breath of fresh air to the narrative, especially with the portrayal of LGBTQ characters. Yet, it felt like Roth introduced them only to snatch them away too soon, leaving their stories unexplored. That felt like a missed opportunity—I wanted to delve deeper into their complexities at a time when Tris and Tobias were in their own tangled mess.
Despite these critiques, Roth’s world-building impressed me more in Insurgent. She painted a broader picture of the factions and the implications of their societal choices, tackling themes of fear and authority that intrigued me. The fear landscapes were a concept I found quite captivating, urging a reflection on facing one’s fears and failures—a theme relevant to us all.
In conclusion, while Insurgent might not have matched the brisk thrill of its predecessor, it set the stage for the final book in the trilogy. It’s a read that will likely resonate with those who enjoyed Divergent but approached with tempered expectations. I’d recommend it to readers who appreciate complex relationships, layered themes, and who are curious to see where Roth takes her characters next. If anything, it left me eager to dive into Allegiant with hopes of closure and growth for Tris and Tobias. So here I go—ready to see if Roth can redeem their arcs. Who’s with me?
Discover more about Insurgent (Divergent, #2) on GoodReads >>