Embracing the Complexity of Simplicity: A Review of “Simplicity” by Mattie Lubchansky
From the moment I laid eyes on the cover of Simplicity, I was captivated by its promise of exploring a commune that not only defies societal norms but also exists in direct contrast to a dystopian world. This curiosity, combined with the intriguing premise of rookie anthropologist Lucius Pasternak delving into a community thriving amidst chaos, had me rooting for this novel from the start. Mattie Lubchansky’s debut unfurls an intricate tapestry of themes around identity, community, and the darker undercurrents of society—capturing my imagination in ways I didn’t expect.
The storyline revolves around Lucius, who finds himself in the quaint yet peculiar hippie commune of Simplicity, established by the Spiritual Association of Peers in 1977. As someone who originates from the oppressive NY Administrative Security Territory (AST) filled with corporate greed and surveillance, Lucius’s journey into Simplicity feels like a breath of fresh air, albeit one tinged with the potential for danger. The contrast between his stifling reality and the commune’s open, collaborative spirit is beautifully depicted. One particularly striking moment is when Lucius describes the community as “a single organism,” encapsulating its ethos of interconnectedness and mutual support.
The characters, particularly Acolyte Amity Crown-Shy and Cleric Obedience Walking-Tree, serve as dynamic gateways into the commune’s philosophy regarding identity and existence. Amity’s interviews — especially their assertion, “We’re stripped down to nothing. Names, gender, whatever. We start over. We choose a new one. Don’t choose at all!” — resonate deeply, challenging preconceptions around selfhood. As a trans man, Lucius is both alienated and liberated by Simplicity’s ideals, and I couldn’t help but feel a sense of recognition and validation in his struggle.
The writing itself flows gracefully, balancing humor and tension effectively. Lubchansky’s narrative style, peppered with surreal elements that seep into Lucius’s dreams, crafts a sense of otherworldliness that kept me engaged. The pacing, particularly during the murder mystery subplot surrounding the community’s missing members, is brisk yet thoughtful, leading to a satisfying, twisty resolution that I found quite rewarding.
While the dark themes of violence and transphobia are present and serve as poignant reminders of societal failings, they are handled with care, weaving into the fabric of the story rather than overpowering it. It’s a challenging read at times, but I believe that makes it all the more significant.
For anyone searching for a narrative that combines community, identity exploration, and a hint of mystery, Simplicity is sure to delight. Mattie Lubchansky has crafted a world that is as enchanting as it is troubling—one that will linger in your thoughts long after you’ve turned the final page. As I reflect on my experience reading this book, I’m left feeling more hopeful and curious about the ways we can build community, even amidst adversity. Whether you’re drawn in by the allure of a communal utopia or the captivating mystery, Simplicity offers layers worth unpacking.
In the end, the book serves as a reminder that even in a chaotic world, the human spirit—when embraced collectively—has the power to reimagine existence. I can’t wait to see where Lubchansky’s journey as an author leads next!
Discover more about Simplicity on GoodReads >>